You're not registered yet. Click here to register. Credits 
Karlheinz Stockhausen - a platform to discuss his works, to anounce forthcoming concerts and to review them.
You can register here for free.
This board has 111 members
1.376 Posts & 180 Topics
Newest posts
 Movement and gestures in Stockhausen's music - Create new reply Your posting rights
Nickname:
 
Subject
 

Message:
[b][/b]
[i][/i]
[u][/u]
[code][/code]
[quote][/quote]
[spoiler][/spoiler]
[url][/url]
[img][/img]
[video][/video]
Smileys
smile
smile2
spook
alien
zunge
rose
shy
clown
devil
death
flash
sick
heart
idee
frage
blush
smokin
mad
sad
wink
frown
crazy
grin
hmm
laugh
mund
oh
rolling_eyes
lil
oh2
shocked
cool
[mail][/mail]
[pre][/pre]
Farben
[rot][/rot]
[blau][/blau]
[gruen][/gruen]
[orange][/orange]
[lila][/lila]
[weiss][/weiss]
[schwarz][/schwarz]
Image Verification
The prevent automated spam replies, please copy the characters into the text field.

Show in post:

 Your reply toQuote
 RE: Movement and gestures in Stockhausen's music

Thanks for this Joe. This answered exactly much of what I was curious about, particularly in terms of the challenges for musicians in learning this aspect of Stockhausen's pieces. Your point about 'theatricality' is also interesting, and it brings to mind a comment Suzanne Stephens made this year during one of the classes where IN FREUNDSCHAFT was being taught. She said there that many performers overdo the gestures because they mistake IN FREUNDSCHAFT as a theatre piece, which, other than the bassoon version, it isn't. But then other pieces clearly are meant to be more 'theatrical' and therefore, she said, offer the interpreter more latitude and opportunity to inject their own personality into the piece. I imagine that knowing where to draw that line, both within and between pieces, must often be a challenge for performers for whom these issues rarely arise in other work they do. Mind you,. I think it's equally (well, maybe not quite equally!) a challenge for audiences, for whom so many of Stockhausen's works provide new opportunities for thinking about how music is conveyed and expressed.

I had wondered about the gestures in the performance of ARIES. I haven't seen the score of the piece, although I do have the score of SIRIUS and couldn't recall those gestures being included there. When SIRIUS was performed here last year, there were many gestures included by all four performers and I remember discussing this briefly with Tristram at the time and my recollection is that he said that, although they weren't indicated in the score, Stockhausen had later indicated that he wanted them to be part of the performance and what they should be. But I'm relying on a vague memory of a short conversation there, so I must ask him again. But it seems to perhaps accord with what you say about Marco's conception of ARIES, formed through his years of working with Stockhausen.

Then comes to mind another question - the use of gesture for more practical reasons. I'm thinking here particularly of SAMSTAGs GRUSS, where the performers move from standing upright to bowing low throughout the piece. The preface to the score says that this is used to help ensure synchronous playing, as it is supposed to be performed without a conductor. But it looks mightily impressive in its own right too. When that piece was performed here a few months ago it was actually performed with a conductor, but the players still followed the directions for the gestures. It was clearly not needed as a means of keeping everyone playing together, but it certainly somehow still seemed right for the piece, in a way that I can't quite define. So I suspect it is often the case that gesture and movement ends up having an impact on an audiences perception of the music beyond what might have originated as a fairly simple or singular purpose on Stockhausen's part. Maybe.



ipar1306, Wed Aug 05, 2015 4:42 am
Fotos hochladen

Zugriffsanfrage von


Diese Seite versucht auf deinen addPics.com Account zuzugreifen.
Aus Sicherheitsgründen, erlaubt addPics.com nur den Zugriff von autorisierten Webseiten. Wenn du dieser Webseite vertraust, kannst du mit einem Klick auf den folgenden Link, den Zugriff erlauben.

autorisieren Aktualisieren

Bitte logge dich mit deinem bereits existierenden Account auf addPics.com ein.


Jetz einloggen!
Neu laden!


Dem Beitrag angehängte Bilder


- noch keine Bilder angehängt.

oder ein bereits hochgeladenes diesem Beitrag hinzufügen.
Nach Ordner filtern: Ordner bearbeiten
  • Mit deiner Emailadresse, verwaltest du all deine Bilder auf addPics.com
  • diese Nutzung von addPics.com ist für dich kostenlos!
  • weitere Informationen findest du hier


Mit dem Upload gebe ich mein Einverständnis, dass meine E-Mail von addPics.com für werbliche Zwecke zum Erhalt von Newslettern genutzt wird. Die E-Mail wird nicht an Dritte weitergegeben und der Newsletter kann jederzeit per E-Mail an unsubscribe@addpics.com abgemeldet werden.

Mit anderen addPics.com Account anmelden
I feel that it could be useful to have a discussion-forum on the music of Stockhausen. There are so many people from all over the world, young and old, learned and eager to get into contact with this musical world: musicologists, composers, musicians, music lovers; people who plan concerts - who write books or have to give lectures and so on. So there should be much stuff, many ideas that we can share. And when we have open questions, there may be people who studied just that and could give a hint or a stimulus. A problem might be the English language, but i feel that is the only possibility that many people who are interested can participate. And we can exercise tolerance to mistakes! Thomas Ulrich
Xobor Xobor Community Software